Cinnamon Bun KnotsSoft baked & tossed in cinnamon sugar and finished with a sweet icing drizzle. Warm, gooey, and the perfect midnight snack. (6)
Nicks Way Garlic KnotsFresh baked knots brushed with garlic butter, parmesan, and finished Nick’s Way. One bite and you won’t want to share. (6)
Mozzarella SticksFried to a golden crisp, stuffed with gooey melted mozzarella. Six sticks, zero regrets.
Underground Wings 6Fresh baked wings baked in Nick’s secret dry rub. Pick your sauce and take it underground.
Your WayStart with our New York-style crust, Nick’s secret pizza sauce, and premium mozzarella. Build it your way with any toppings you want. Simple. Perfect. No rules.
The Red LineA real New York Margherita pizza. No gimmicks, no extras—just a bold classic that speaks for itself, finished Nick’s Way.
The Smoke ShowThe Smoke Show is pepperoni with attitude, drenched in hot honey. Get ready—this is the one you’ll be telling everyone about.
Nicks WayNick’s secret pizza sauce, loaded with pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, and onions, then finished with Nick’s Way herb seasoning and a golden garlic butter crust. Sweet heat, savory bite, and a smell that hits you the second the box opens.
The Midnight PieCreamy ricotta, fresh spinach, and melted mozzarella on our crispy NY crust— a comforting late-night classic, warm, smooth, and exactly what you want when it’s almost time to crash!
Caprese PizzaFresh mozzarella, ripe tomatoes, fragrant basil, a drizzle of olive oil and a balsamic glaze finish on our hand-stretched dough. Simple, fresh, and made the way it was meant to be.
Meat Lovers PizzaLoaded with pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and ham — our Meat Lovers is built for those who don’t compromise. Every bite is pure, unapologetic flavor.
Personal pizzaOne pizza, made just for you. Choose your topping, we handle the rest — hot, fresh, and at your door.
The PizzaritoA crispy taco shell made entirely from baked mozzarella cheese, stuffed with pepperoni and fresh Caesar salad for the perfect combination of cheesy crunch and fresh flavor. A one-of-a-kind creation you won’t find anywhere else.
Veggie PizzaA fresh blend of green peppers, onions, mushrooms, and black olives piled on top of our signature pizza sauce and melted cheese
PizzadillaYour favorite pizza ingredients folded into a crispy grilled tortilla with loads of melted mozzarella. Build it your way with your choice of meats, veggies, and sauces.
StromboliStromboli packed with ham, pepperoni, sausage and mozzarella cheese, finished with dried oregano and our signature garlic butter sauce.
Donate a PizzaWe are matching. 50% of your donation to help feed Tampa! Help your community ensure there are no hungry neighbors left!
2 Large Pizza DealTwo large pizzas at an unbeatable price — perfect for feeding the family or the whole crew. Choose your favorite toppings and we’ll make them fresh to order, just the way you like it. Made fresh, made local — that’s the Tampa Pizza Delivery promise.
Wing+Fries+Garlic Knot ComboCrispy, golden wing fries paired with soft, buttery garlic knots brushed with garlic herb seasoning and finished with parmesan. It’s the perfect mix of crunch and comfort—savory, shareable, and built for dipping. Comes hot, fresh, and made to hit the spot whether you’re snacking or turning it into a full meal.
Kickoff ComboOne large pizza with up to 3 toppings + 12 Underground wings tossed in your choice of sauce. Game day, handled.
End Zone FeastTwo large pizzas with up to 3 toppings each + 12 Underground wings in your choice of sauce + a 2-liter soda. The full Sunday spread for the whole watch party.
Fried Oreos (10 Ct)Golden, crispy, and pure Florida Fair nostalgia. We batter classic Oreos and fry them to a puffy golden-brown, then dust them warm with powdered sugar for that gooey, melty center you’re craving. Same treat, same rush — no wristband required
Fried Oreos (5Ct)Golden, crispy, and pure Florida Fair nostalgia. We batter classic Oreos and fry them to a puffy golden-brown, then dust them warm with powdered sugar for that gooey, melty center you’re craving. Same treat, same rush — no wristband required
